What Is A Co-Op And Should You Buy One?
Scott Steinberg5-minute read
November 11, 2021
What is a co-op? How does co-op housing differ from living in a condominium or garden-variety single-family apartment? And what does it mean to be part of a housing cooperative? These are good questions – and ones that you’re probably wondering about if you’ve never lived in a big city like Washington, DC, or New York.
In effect, cooperative housing (also referred to as co-ops for short) is a type of homeownership common to larger real estate markets. In some ways, co-op housing operates similarly to condo living. But at the same time, it’s worth noting that they are not one and the same – and rather than each unit being independently owned in a co-op, all tenants hold a stake in the building’s housing together.
Note that Rocket Mortgage® does not currently offer co-op financing. However, the below article explains more about what a co-op is and may help you decide whether it’s the right form of housing for you to invest in.
Cooperative housing (commonly described by referring to an individual co-op) is a type of homeownership common to apartment buildings in big cities such as New York. For practical intents and purposes, a co-op can be defined as a building that is jointly owned by a corporation made up of all its inhabitants. When you buy into a co-op, you’re not purchasing a piece of property – rather, you’re personally buying shares in a nonprofit corporation that allows you to live in the residence.
For sake of clarity, when you buy an apartment or condo, you’re typically buying the interior contents that lie behind a numbered door – one of many individual units. Under the terms of a co-op, everyone who lives in the co-op is considered a shareholder, and the size of the apartment that you inhabit determines your stake in the building. Everyone who resides on premises enjoys access to certain common areas of the building (which, like the interior and exterior of the property, are owned by the corporation). Likewise, they all share in the expenses and responsibility for maintaining the upkeep of the property.
A co-op is governed by a board of directors who will establish a set of by-laws that outline rules for inhabiting and respectfully cohabiting the building. But every shareholder also gets to enjoy a say in how the overall building will be run.
How Does Co-Op Housing Work?
Although it’s common to think of condos and co-ops as being similar, it’s important to remember that they don’t operate in identical fashion.
Case in point: When you buy a condo, you’re effectively buying ownership of an individual unit in the building in which you’ll reside. As you hold the deed to the property, you also get to benefit from any equity or additional value that accrues in the property as well. As an added bonus, you may also enjoy a relative measure of flexibility when it comes to renovating, upgrading, or performing DIY updates to your condo unit. Purchasing and acquiring financing for a condo is also generally easier as well.
On the flip side, if you elect to buy into a co-op, you’re effectively buying shares in the corporation that owns the overall property. In other words: While you’re paying for the right to live in a specific unit of a building, you don’t actually own this unit outright – and may have fewer options when it comes to making changes, additions or renovations to the residence. Buying a co-op also tends to involve a more demanding application process and may involve being interviewed by the co-op board and financially vetted before you’re approved to purchase shares.
As briefly touched on prior, a co-op is a nonprofit organization. This means that it comes with a board of directors and shareholders as well. Shareholders (those who buy into the co-op) own a portion of the company that owns the building in which they reside. The co-op board is responsible for setting policies and making decisions that are in the co-op’s best interest. Policies handed down by the board, which govern life within the co-op, are generally referred to as by-laws – and these by-laws commonly come in the form of rules and restrictions. For instance, members of the co-op may be prevented from subletting their apartment or require that all new shareholders seeking to buy into the co-op (aka to buy out an existing resident) must be preapproved by the board in advance.
All co-op owners are responsible for the co-op’s mutual financial obligations. Payments often cover common expenses such as building maintenance and upkeep, renovations or improvements to common areas, underlying mortgages attached to the property and its units, etc.
What Do Co-Op Homes Look Like?
In general, co-op housing will appear in the form of an apartment that’s part of a large building in a big city. However, several other co-op models exist. Also worth noting: A co-op can also take the form of a townhouse, duplex, or any other type of available housing – including single-family homes, mobile homes, and groups of tiny houses situated on co-op land.
Different Types Of Co-Ops
In fact, many different types of co-ops are available. You may encounter consumer cooperatives, worker cooperatives, producer cooperatives, and more. As a general rule of thumb, all exist with a stated purpose to help groups of people with shared interests work toward a common goal.
Advantages And Disadvantages Of Co-Op Living
As with any form of housing, co-op living comes with upsides and downsides attached – including pros and cons you’ll want to be aware of before buying into a co-op.
Pros Of Co-Ops
- Lower purchase price: If you live in a large city such as Washington, DC, or New York, you’ll generally find that co-ops tend to be much cheaper and require smaller down payments than if you purchased a condo.
- Less responsibility: If you’ve ever owned a piece of property, then you know that you’re responsible for any maintenance needs that come up. Owning a co-op apartment may feel similar to renting in that you’ll find that you aren’t responsible for major items of upkeep that take place beyond the boundaries of your own unit.
- Better insight into your neighbors: Because co-op boards require detailed and extensive financial records and character references from applicants, you’ll at least have some idea who they are and some sense of any interests or values that they may share.
- Tax benefits: Properties in select areas of the country may allow you to deduct interest on your loan for your share of the property, and your share of the interest on the blanket mortgage that the co-op holds for the building. Likewise, certain maintenance fees may be tax deductible. If you have questions, contact a qualified tax professional.
Cons Of Co-Ops
- Higher monthly fees: Although the purchase price of a co-op often comes in lower than buying a condo, monthly expenses and charges tend to be higher, based on what expenses that these fees cover (such as utilities, parking, etc.).
- Greater restrictions: Don’t forget to read the by-laws in-depth before buying into a co-op. These rules will sketch out what is and isn’t permissible for building residents (like if you can have pets or if you can sublease your apartment). A careful reading can also help you get a better sense as to what renovations, upgrades, or changes to your apartment unit can be made as well.
- Limited buying pool: By-laws incorporated into co-op housing residences can place significant restrictions on shareholders’ ability to resell their shares, and to divest themselves of real estate holdings. Then again, keep in mind that during COVID, co-ops held value better than condos in NYC because co-op boards weed out financially risky prospects.
Cooperative Housing FAQs
As you might imagine, prospective co-op applicants may have many frequently asked questions when it comes to cooperative housing. Below, you’ll find answers to several common queries.
Q: What’s the difference between a condo and a co-op?
A: Differences between a condo versus a co-op largely come down to whether you own the individual property unit, or hold shares in a building, respectively. Condos typically offer owners more options when it comes to renovating or rehabbing their units and are easier to finance. Co-ops (in which you buy shares of a property), are generally more stringent when it comes to modifying the residence and who’s allowed to live in the building.
Q: Should I buy a co-op?
A: That depends on your individual situation. Do you want less responsibility? To live in a property that’s harder to divest yourself of, but has a more stringent qualification process on who’s approved to live in the building? Are you comfortable with owning shares in a non-profit housing corporation vs. an actual piece of property in the form of a unit (and purchasing them using a share loan instead of a mortgage)? You’ll need to consider a variety of these factors – including how hard it might be to resell your shares on the back end – especially if you’re considering purchasing a co-op as a means of investing in real estate.
Q: Can I finance a co-op purchase with a mortgage?
A: In short, no: Because co-op owners do not own real estate, the financing process is slightly different from a standard mortgage application. Rather than apply for a home mortgage loan, you’ll need to take out something called a share loan instead. During the application process, you’ll provide information to your lender about how the co-op operates. The lender will also look into the board of directors and take a look at the underlying mortgage. Some co-ops already have existing relationships with certain lenders, which can make the financing process much easier.
The Bottom Line: Could A Co-Op Home Be Right For You?
At the time that you buy into a co-op, you’re not purchasing a specific piece of property but rather investing in shares of stock in a housing cooperative. Commonly confused with condos, co-ops can often take the form of apartments, duplexes, townhomes and other traditional forms of residential structure, but operate according to a different set of rules entirely.
Co-ops generally offer a more affordable way to buy into housing in big cities. But at the same time, governed by boards and bylaws and equipped with more stringent application processes, they often come with more rules and restrictions attached. Be sure to take ample time to do your research and homework when deciding if you’re going to be a tenant or if you’re going to buy a co-op. Rocket Mortgage does not offer financing on co-ops. If you have further questions, be sure to check out the Rocket Mortgage Home Buying Guide for additional resources and home buying tips.
See What You Qualify For
Condo Vs. Co-Op: Know The Difference
Home Buying - 6-minute read
Andrew Dehan - November 12, 2021
Condos and co-ops are commonly confused housing types. Learn all about the similarities, differences and financing options for condos and co-ops here.