Should I pay off my mortgage or invest?

This article is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, medical, legal, financial, or tax advice. You should consult with a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Consumers should independently verify that any services, products, or programs referenced meet their needs and comply with applicable requirements.

Deciding whether to pay off your mortgage or invest your extra money is a common financial dilemma. On one hand, eliminating your mortgage debt can provide a sense of financial freedom and security. On the other, investing those extra funds could potentially yield higher long-term returns. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, as the best choice depends on your individual financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance.

In this article, we'll explore the key factors to consider when deciding whether to prioritize investing in real estate by paying off your mortgage early or investing your extra cash elsewhere.

Paying off your mortgage vs. investing: A breakdown

If you have extra money in your monthly budget, you may be thinking of paying off your mortgage early or investing. Using it to make extra payments on your mortgage offers a guaranteed benefit by reducing how much interest accrues on your loan. It can also get you out of your monthly mortgage payment more quickly. With the median U.S. loan payment being almost $2,650, based on data from Redfin as of June 2026, paying off your mortgage early can free up a lot of space in your budget.

You could also use that money to invest and potentially earn a greater return than the interest savings. Choosing between one and the other requires carefully analyzing your loan, investment goals, time horizon, and more. In many cases, taking a balanced approach might be the best path forward.

Mortgage interest savings comparison

When you get a mortgage, it comes with a mortgage rate. This rate expresses the cost of borrowing money. For a simplified example, if you get a loan for $100 at 5% interest, the loan’s balance would be $105 at the end of the year if you make no payments.

Mortgages are a bit more complicated because interest typically accrues daily and you make payments monthly. Your monthly payments cover the entirety of the accrued interest plus a portion of the loan’s principal, amortizing the loan over time.

Amortization describes the process through which your loan’s balance falls over time as you make payments. Early on, more interest accrues due to the loan’s larger balance, so more of each payment goes toward interest. As time passes, the loan’s balance falls and less interest accrues each month. That means more of your monthly payment goes toward the loan principal. You can use this mortgage calculator Rocket Mortgage to get more information about how much interest you may pay on a particular loan amount using current rate information and your desired mortgage term. You can break down your progress as you pay off your mortgage with this amortization calculator.

You can look at paying off your mortgage ahead of schedule as getting a guaranteed return equal to your mortgage’s interest rate. Other investments can offer different return potential but typically come with risk.

This table shows an example of how much money you could save by paying off a $400,000 mortgage in 20 years rather than 30, assuming a 6.5% interest rate.

With a 20-year repayment period, you pay about $450 more per month but save nearly $200,000 in interest over the life of the loan.

Investment ROI comparison over 18 years

If you’re not using your extra funds to pay off your mortgage, another option for bettering your financial future is to invest. Investment comes with risk and volatility, but in general you should see a return on your money.

Potential returns and risk depend on your investment portfolio. For example, between 1926 and 2024, a portfolio investing entirely in stocks returned an average of 10.5% per year, with a one-year high of 54.2% and a one-year low of a 43.1% loss. On the other hand, a 100% bond portfolio returned an average of 5% with a one-year high of 32.6% and a one-year low of a 13.1% loss.

Imagine that instead of putting your extra money toward your mortgage, you invest it in a portfolio that is 60% stocks and 40% bonds. Historically, that portfolio has produced an 8.8% return, so after 18 years, you could have $220,627.40. After 20 years, you could have $272,541.78.

In this example, you come out ahead by investing. However, keep in mind that your returns may not mirror the historical average, and there is a risk you could lose money.

Pros of paying off your mortgage

There are several reasons to consider paying off your mortgage ahead of schedule.

• Guaranteed return at your mortgage rate. Every dollar you put toward your mortgage means less interest that accrues, saving you money.
• Improves cash flow. Once your loan is paid off, you’ll have eliminated what is likely your biggest bill from your monthly budget.
• Peace of mind. Being debt-free and especially mortgage-free can be a weight off your shoulders. You no longer need to worry about financial emergencies leading to missed loan payments and foreclosure.
• Eases financial risk. Having a paid-off house can reduce your monthly spending and insulate you from rising costs of housing or increases in other areas of your budget. You can also access your equity with a home equity loan or home equity line of credit (HELOC) if you need it later for large expenses. Rocket Mortgage does not offer HELOCs at this time but you can use a home equity loan many different ways.

Cons of paying off your mortgage

There are also drawbacks to paying your home loan off, so consider these drawbacks before you commit.

• Opportunity cost. If you use your extra cash to pay off your mortgage, you may miss out on better returns from investing.
• Illiquid (money is tied to house). Putting extra money toward your mortgage payment locks that money into your home equity. That can be hard to tap for a source of cash if you need it.
• Might lose out on mortgage interest tax deduction. If you’re itemizing your taxes, you can deduct your mortgage interest on your tax return, effectively reducing the cost of your loan. Paying off your mortgage means losing this perk. You might also have to pay a prepayment penalty.

Choosing to invest vs. paying off your mortgage

Investing your extra cash rather than paying off your mortgage can be appealing to people who have cheap mortgages or who value flexibility. Keep these pros and cons in mind.

Pros of investing your money

Some benefits of investing your money include:

• Potentially higher long-term gains. Depending on your mortgage rate and portfolio construction, investing may produce higher returns in the long run, putting you in an overall better situation financially.
• Liquidity (depending on investment vehicle). As long as you don’t invest in a tax-advantaged account, investing gives you easier access to your money as compared to making extra mortgage payments.
• Diversification. When you invest, you can invest in many different types of securities, giving your portfolio more diversification. If you put all your cash toward your mortgage, you’ve invested exclusively in your home.

Cons of investing your money

Investing also has drawbacks, such as:

• Market volatility. In the long run, investing tends to produce positive returns, but the returns are volatile. You might lose half or more of your portfolio in just a year or two and need to be ready for that volatility.
• Returns aren’t guaranteed. While investing has historically produced a positive return, nothing is guaranteed. Your portfolio may gain value, lose value, or hold steady.
• Risk of reactivity. Investing requires a steady hand and willingness to weather the storm. You can significantly worsen your returns if you try to time the market or panic when prices swing.
• Requires long-term horizon. Successful investing requires a long-term outlook. For example, during the 2008 housing crisis, the market fell significantly in September and did not recover to its previous levels until 2011, roughly 3 years later.

Choosing to do both: Pay off your mortgage and invest

The good news is that you don’t need to choose just one or the other. There’s no reason you can’t put some money toward paying off your mortgage and some toward investing. In fact, that’s likely the best move for most people.

How you split your money between paying off loans and investing depends on your goals, risk tolerance, and financial situation.

For example, you might use this order of priority:

• Contribute to retirement accounts up to your employer’s matching level
• Pay off high-interest debt such as personal loans or credit cards, which are the kinds of debts lenders consider when you apply for a mortgage
• Add additional funds to retirement accounts to keep you on track for your retirement goals
• Split remaining money between further investing and paying off your mortgage

If you don’t have extra funds in your monthly budget, you can use money from things like tax refunds or bonuses that you don’t account for in your budget to achieve these goals. You may also want to consider whether making extra principal-only payments on your mortgage balance or biweekly mortgage payments are good strategies for meeting your goals.

Other considerations

Deciding how to balance paying off your mortgage and investing depends on many different factors. Some things to consider include:

• Life stage. Younger people may find investing more appealing because they have a longer time horizon for their portfolio to grow while older people nearing retirement may prioritize paying off their home so they can reduce their spending.
• Emergency cushion. If you lack an emergency fund, you should likely focus on building one before putting funds toward either investment or paying off a mortgage. Having an emergency fund and a mortgage payment that works for your budget can keep you from becoming house poor.
• Interest rate environment. If interest rates are high, paying off your mortgage becomes more appealing. However, if you get a mortgage at a low rate, it can be advantageous to keep it and focus on investing.
• Personal goals. If you want to maximize your flexibility, investing is probably a better choice because it keeps your money more liquid by not tying it up in home equity. Those aiming for generational wealth may also choose to invest due to the long time horizon involved. If you dislike the feeling of being in debt, you’ll likely prioritize paying off your loan.

The bottom line: Pay off your mortgage, invest, or do both

The decision between paying off your mortgage or investing does not have to be a binary one. You can, and likely should, do both. How you choose to balance those two goals depends on your personal goals and financial situation. Paying off your mortgage means a guaranteed return and reducing your monthly expenditures, while investing could produce better returns in the long run so long as you can manage the risk.

If you want to see how much you can save by making extra mortgage payments, you can use Rocket Mortgage’s mortgage payoff calculator. And if you’re interested in learning more about getting a home loan or refinancing a current loan, you can reach out to Rocket Mortgage.