Restrictive Covenants In Real Estate: What They Are And How They Affect You

In real estate, restrictive covenants limit how homeowners (or tenants they lease the property to) can use the property. They’re common in communities with a homeowners association (HOA).

There are benefits and drawbacks of restrictive covenants as well as different types of covenants you might see when house hunting.

What Is A Restrictive Covenant?

A restrictive covenant is a clause in a property deed that outlines limits on an owner's use of a property. Often these types of agreements are made with homeowners associations. In the case of an HOA, restrictive covenants are general rules that members of your HOA vote on that all property owners living in the area must follow.

The covenant may include actions you can’t take with your property, like raising livestock or running a business from your home. It will also include actions you must take, like mowing your lawn regularly and/or maintaining your landscaping to HOA standards.

The covenants you need to follow will vary depending on where you live. Some HOA communities have many restrictions, some have only a few and others have none at all.

You can usually find them in the HOA document known as the CC&R agreement (covenants, conditions and restrictions).

Types Of Restrictive Covenants

There are several common types of restrictive covenants you might encounter when you shop for a home.

Limitations On Home Color

HOAs can be very picky about paint color and include this restriction in many CC&Rs. Most paint limitations specify a list of acceptable home colors and ban all others. Assume your design choices will only be between neutral shades if you’re looking at a home with a covenant on paint colors.

Rent And Lease Restrictions

You’ll have to check your CC&R first if you want to rent out your home. Many HOAs severely limit your ability to rent or lease out your home. You may only be able to rent out your home for a few months of the year, or you may not be able to rent your home out at all.

Restrictions On Home Businesses

Your CC&R may include a covenant that prohibits you from operating a business out of your home. This covenant can quickly create a big problem if you’re self-employed. While most HOAs won’t care if you turn your spare bedroom into a home office, anything that causes an increase in traffic for your neighbors may set off red flags and lead to you getting fined.

Limitations On Permissible Pets

Some HOAs place limitations on the types of pets you can have on your property. Your CC&R can also put limits on the size of your pets. For example, your HOA could tell you that you can only own a small- or medium-sized dog.

Your HOA can also put restrictions on the breed of dog you may own. Many covenants ban dog breeds, like pit bulls and German shepherds, that some people deem highly aggressive.

Requirements For Exterior Maintenance

Your CC&R will likely lay out what type of maintenance you need to perform on your property. You may need to mow your lawn every so often, remove holiday lights after a certain date or only place your trash outside on trash day. The HOA will make sure the exterior of your property is up to code if you live in a development that provides exterior maintenance.

Restrictions On Exterior Constructions

CC&Rs may include restrictions on modifications and buildings you make on your property. You may not be able to build a shed, fence or detached garage without first getting the design approved by the HOA. Some CC&Rs ban additional construction altogether.

Required Maintenance

In addition to rules on what you can’t do with your home, your restrictive covenants can include things you need to do. Maintenance standards may dictate rules like how often you need to repaint your home or fix a fence. Depending on your HOA and your agreement, the cost of maintenance might come out of your HOA fees.

Are There Limits On Restrictive Covenants?

There are limits on the specific covenants your HOA can place on the development. For example, they can’t use restrictive covenants for discriminatory purposes based on things like religion, race and sexuality. Nor can they implement covenants that violate state or federal laws.

Your HOA can’t fine or punish you for something not addressed in the list of restrictive covenants you signed when you moved in. Your HOA also can’t engage in selective enforcement practices, which is fining you for an action that other people who live under your HOA’s rules are taking.

History Of Restrictive Covenants

In the past, restrictive covenants were used to maintain the demographic conditions of certain neighborhoods. For example, in the 1940s, it was common for covenants to bar home sales to Black families.

However, the practice is illegal today. It was outlawed as part of the Fair Housing Act passed in 1968.

FAQs About Restrictive Covenants

The concept of restrictive covenants can be confusing at best. Here are the answers to a few frequently asked questions to help you better understand your rights and responsibilities.

Are restrictive covenants in real estate legal?

Yes, but only to an extent. HOAs can’t use restrictive covenants to enforce discriminatory practices. Any covenants restricting who can live in the neighborhood or discriminate against an individual based on a protected class are illegal and unenforceable. These incl