Woman reading a book at home in a comfy arm chair.

Loan Modification Vs. Refinance – Which Is Best For You?

7-minute read

You might want to refinance your loan if you’re having trouble making your mortgage payments or if you want to take advantage of a lower interest rate. However, you may also want to request a loan modification from your lender. Refinances and loan modifications both have their own benefits and drawbacks. It’s important to do your research before you decide.

Let’s go over some of the differences between refinances and loan modification. We’ll let you know when a modification is better than a refinance – and vice versa. Finally, we’ll tell you how to apply for both.

What Is A Loan Modification?

A loan modification is a change to the original terms of your mortgage loan. Unlike a refinance, a loan modification doesn’t pay off your current mortgage and replace it with a new one. Instead, it directly changes the conditions of your loan. You can only get a loan modification through your current lender because they must consent to the terms. Some of the things you might want to adjust include:  

  • Loan term changes: If you’re having trouble making your monthly payments, your lender can modify your loan and extend your term. This gives you more time to repay your loan and reduces the amount you must pay every month.
  • Interest rate reduction: If interest rates are lower now than when you locked into your mortgage loan, you may be able to modify your loan and get a lower rate. This lowers your monthly payment without changing your term.
  • Loan structure changes: You may be able to modify your loan from an adjustable interest structure to a fixed rate. This can be beneficial if you now live on a fixed income and you need a more predictable monthly payment.
  • Principal reduction: Your lender may agree to reduce the amount you owe on your loan. However, these modifications are rare. You can usually only get a principal reduction if no other possible solution will help you avoid foreclosure. You usually also have to subscribe to a repayment plan to qualify for a principal reduction. A repayment plan allows your lender to see if you can stay on top of your new payments. Your lender may agree to settle some of your principal after you complete the repayment plan trial period.

Lenders have no obligation to accept your request for a modification or negotiate your principal. This means that getting a modification is usually more difficult than refinancing. However, if your lender believes that you won’t be able to pay off your loan in the long term without a modification, they’re more likely to accommodate you. Every lender has their own standards when it comes to who qualifies for a modification and what types of modifications they offer.

You may receive offers from settlement companies to help you get a loan modification if you’re behind on your mortgage. These companies negotiate with your lender on your behalf and can make getting a loan modification easier. If you do decide to work with one of these companies, do your research on the provider before you agree to any contract. The last thing you need is a high-fee contract with a settlement company if you’re already behind on your mortgage payments.

When Should You Use A Loan Modification?

It makes sense to seek a loan modification before a refinance in some instances. Let’s take a look at some of those times. 

  • Your loan is underwater. An underwater mortgage is when you owe more money on your home than your property is worth. Your loan can go underwater if you miss payments early in your term or you live in an area where property values are falling. Most lenders won’t allow you to refinance more than your home is worth. Though there are streamline options that can allow you to change your rate and term without an appraisal, you must meet specific criteria to qualify for each option. Ask your lender for a direct modification to simplify the process and help you when you’re underwater.
  • You need a principal reduction. You cannot reduce your mortgage principal with a refinance. A loan modification may be able to help if you know you owe too much money on your home and you’re likely to go into foreclosure.
  • You’re behind on your monthly payments. A lender won’t allow you to refinance unless you’re current on your monthly payments. Some types of refinances for underwater loans require that you have at least six consecutive on-time payments to qualify. Seek a modification if you can’t catch up on your monthly payments before you apply.

How To Modify Your Loan

Every lender has their own standards for loan modification. Most require you to apply with financial documentation that proves you need the modification. Some of these documents include:

  • Proof of income: Your lender needs to know that you don’t have enough income to cover your current mortgage. Proof of income can include a salary agreement or contract from your employer that states your hourly rate or annual income. Your lender might ask for a profit and loss balance if you’re self-employed.
  • Your most recent tax return: Your lender will likely need your entire tax return when you request a modification.
  • Bank statements: Your lender might ask for bank statements to confirm your assets.
  • A hardship statement: Your lender needs to know why you want a modification. Your hardship letter tells your lender why you can no longer make your monthly payments or pay for your entire loan balance. You may also want to include supplementary documentation along with your letter to further illustrate your situation. Things like medical bills or a termination letter from your previous employer can increase your chances of approval. 

Contact your lender and ask how to apply if you think you qualify for a modification. Keep in mind that your lender may refuse your request. You may still qualify for a refinance if that happens to you.

See how much cash you could get from your home.

Apply online with Rocket Mortgage® to see your options.

What Does It Mean To Refinance Your Mortgage?

You replace your existing loan with a new mortgage when you refinance. This allows you to change the terms of your loan. You can also use your equity to take cash out of your home. You might want to refinance to:

  • Lengthen your mortgage term. You lower your monthly mortgage payment when you refinance to a longer mortgage term. This can help you avoid foreclosure if your income is now lower than when you got your loan.
  • Shorten your term. You can also shorten your mortgage term with a refinance. Your monthly payment increases when you shorten your term. However, you own your home sooner and save money over time in interest.
  • Take a lower interest rate. A refinance can help you lock in a lower rate if interest rates are lower now than when you got your loan.
  • Change your loan type. It might be beneficial to refinance to a new loan type if you have more than 20% equity in your home. For example, if you have an FHA loan, you’ll pay for mortgage insurance throughout the life of the loan if you put less than 10% down. However, you can cancel private mortgage insurance on a conventional loan as soon as you reach 20% equity. Many homeowners refinance their FHA loan to a conventional loan after they achieve 20% equity for this same reason.
  • Take a cash-out refinance. A cash-out refinance allows you to draw money from your home equity to cover outside expenses. You take on a higher-balance loan and in exchange, your lender gives you the difference in cash. For example, imagine that your principal loan balance is $200,000 and you want to cover $20,000 worth of credit card debt with your equity. A cash-out refinance means you’d take a loan with a $220,000 balance and your lender would give you $20,000 in cash. Mortgage interest rates are lower than the interest rates on other types of loans and credit cards, which allows you to save money when you cash out.

Unlike a loan modification, you don’t need to refinance with your current lender. Unsatisfied with your lender? A refinance can allow you to switch to a new lender’s system.

When Should You Refinance?

Let’s take a look at a couple of times when it makes sense to take a refinance over a modification. 

  • You’re not underwater on your loan. Though there are special refinance programs that can help you adjust the terms of an underwater loan, refinancing is much easier when you have equity.
  • You want to take cash out of your equity. You can take cash out of your home equity to cover outside bills if you meet equity standards. This isn’t possible with a loan modification.

How To Refinance Your Loan

You’ll choose a lender, submit an application and offer your personal financial documentation for underwriting. Your lender will usually give you the option to lock in your interest rate as well. This protects you against market interest rate movements.

After you lock in your rate, your lender underwrites your loan to make sure you qualify to refinance. With most types of refinances, you must get another appraisal before you can close on your new loan. The appraisal ensures the lender that they’re not loaning you more money than your home is worth. Once the appraisal and underwriting processes are complete, your lender will give you a Closing Disclosure. The Closing Disclosure tells you more about the terms of your loan and your closing costs. You’ll then attend a closing meeting and sign on your new loan.

Get approved to refinance.

See expert-recommended refinance options and customize them to fit your budget.

Summary

A loan modification is different from a refinance. When you take a loan modification, you change the terms of your loan directly through your lender. Most lenders agree to modifications only if you’re at immediate risk of foreclosure. A loan modification can also help you change the terms of your loan if your home loan is underwater. Contact your lender if you think you qualify for a modification.

On the other hand, a refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a new loan. When you refinance, you can change your loan’s term, your interest rate and even your loan type. You can also take cash out of your equity with a cash-out refinance. To get a refinance, you’ll go through an application process that’s similar to the process you went through to buy your home.

In This Article